The Evolution of India's Environmental Policy
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.36808/if/2021/v147i8/165166Keywords:
Political Will, Exclusionary, Participatory, Judiciary, Standoff, Conventions.Abstract
Environmental policies are influenced by a multitude of factors and determine how environmental resources are accessed, apportioned, consumed, conserved and governed. Using existing literature, the paper tracks the evolution of India's environmental policy post-independence. We discuss the key milestones in the country's environmental journey and their drivers. We found that India's environmental policy took shape in the 1970s and 1980s when environmental obligations were included in the constitution and federal laws were framed. It led to the creation of an extensive protected area network, albeit by overlooking the needs of the forest dwellers. In the 1990s, the judiciary innovated by creating space for civil society to take up environmental issues and played an active role. This period also saw a gradual shift towards participatory natural resource management and collaboration between the state and the civil society. However, by the early 21st century this bonhomie weakened when civil society successfully secured the tenurial rights of the forest dwellers. The last decade has seen a weakening of participatory forest management, a shift towards re-centralization, and a relentless tussle between a strong state and a resilient civil society. The key influencing factors of environmental policy change were discerned as international diplomacy, political leadership, judicial activism, civil society advocacy and environmental disasters.References
Agarwal A. and Narain S. (1991). Global warming in an unequal world: A case of environmental colonialism. Centre for Science and Environment, New Delhi, 39 pp.
Aggarwal M. (2018). India's new compensatory afforestation rules dilute rights of forest dwellers. Mongabay, 23rdAug, 2018. Retrieved on 12th July, 2021 at 08:10 am from https://india.mongabay.com/2018/08/indias-new-compensatory-afforestation-rules-dilute-rights-of-forest-dwellers/
Aggarwal A. and Yokozoka, N. (2002). Environmental Capacity-Building: India's Democratic Polities and Environmental Management. In: Weidner H., Janicke M. (eds) Capacity Building in National Environmental PolicySpringer, Berlin, Heidelberg. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3662-04794-1_11.
Asher and Agarwal (2007). Recognizing the Historic Injustice: Campaign for the. Forest Rights Act 2006. National Centre for Advocacy Studies, Pune.
Bahree M. (2014). Indian government sets up committee to review environmental laws: Not everyone is happy with it. Forbes, 16thOctober, 2014. Retrieved on 12th July, 2021 at 11:48, fromhttps://www.forbes.com/sites/meghabahree/2014/10/16/i ndian-govt-sets-up-committee-to-review-environmental-lawsnoteveryone-is-happy-with-it/?sh=57cdac584deb
Banerjee A. (2007). Joint forest management in West Bengal. In: Forests, people and power: The political ecology of reform in South Asia (O. Springate-Baginski and P. Blaikie Eds.) pp. 221-260. London and Sterling, Earthscan.
Banerjee S. (2015). Parliamentary Standing Committee rejects TSR Subramanian report on environmental laws, Down to th Earth, 30 July, 2015. Retrieved on 12th Jul, 2021 at 12:10 from
Barnes C., Van Laerhoven F. and Driessen P. P. (2016). Advocating for change? How a civil society-led coalition influences the implementation of the forest rights act in India. World Development, 84(162-175).
Bisht D.S. (2019). How the Centre is diluting green clearance norms. Down to Earth, 15th Jan, 2019. Retrieved on 3rd July, 2021 at 23:00 from
Brockington, D. (2002). Fortress conservation: the preservation of the Mkomazi Game Reserve, Tanzania. Indiana University Press, Bloomington, Indiana. 224 pp.
Broome N.P., Desor S., Kothari A. and Bose A. (2014). Changing Paradigms in Wildlife Conservation in India. In: Democratizing Forest Governance in India (S. Lele and A. Menon, Eds.), New Delhi, Oxford University Press.
CFRLA (2016). Promise and Performance: Ten Years of the Forest Rights Act in India. Citizens' Report on Promise and Performance of The Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act, 2006, after 10 years of its Enactment. December 2016. Produced as part of Community Forest Rights-Learning and Advocacy Process (CFR-LA), India, 2016.
Chopra K. (2017). Development and Environmental Policy. In: Development and Environmental Policy in India (pp. 112). Springer, Singapore.
Choudhary S. (2019). Why proposed changes to Forest Act have stirred up a hornets' nest, Livemint. Retrieved on 17th Jul, 2021 at 18:21 fromhttps://www.livemint.com/politics/policy/why-proposed-changes-to-forest-act-have-stirred-up-ahornetsnest-1560886010911.html
Chowdhury N. (2014). From judicial activism to adventurismthe Godavarman case in the supreme court of India, Asia Paccific Journal of Environmental Law, 17:177-189.
Desai B.H., & Sidhu B. (2010). On the Quest for Green Courts in India. J. Ct. Innovation, 3(1): 79-111.
Divan S. and Rosencranz A. (2001). Environmental law and policy in India. Delhi, Oxford University Press. 837 pp.
Dubash N.K. (2009). Toward a progressive Indian and global climate politics. Centre for Policy Research Climate Initiative. Working Paper 2009 1, New Delhi, India.
Dubash N.K. (2013). The politics of climate change in India: narratives of equity and co benefits, Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change, 4(3): 191-201.
Dubash N.K., Khosla R., Kelkar U. and Lele S. (2018). India and climate change: Evolving ideas and increasing policy engagement, Annual Review of Environment and Resources, 43: 395-424.
Dwivedi O.P. (2006). India's Environmental Policies, Programmes and Stewardship. Springer. 235 pp.
Ellis-Petersen H. (2020). India plans to fell ancient forest to create 40 new coalfields. The Guardian, 8th Aug, 2020. Retrieved on 11th July, 2021 at 23:53 from https://www.theguardian.com/ world/2020/aug/08/india-prime-minister-narendra-modi-planstofell-ancient-forest-to-create-40-new-coal-fields
ENVIS (2011). National Workshop on JFM, Dehradun, 27-28 June 2011. Proceedings. Dehradun, Forest Research Institute.
ET Bureau. (2014). Government sets up committee to review environment-related laws. The Economic Times, 3rd September, 2014. Retrieved on 12th July, 2021 at 10:54 from https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/economy/policy/g overnment-sets-up-committee-to-review-environment-relatedlaws/articleshow/41561593.cms
Forrester J.W. (1992). Policies, decisions and information sources for modeling. European Journal of Operational Research, 59 (1): 42-63.
Gadgil M., Krishnan B.J., Ganeshaiah K.N., Vijayan V.S., Borges R., Sukumar R., Noronha L., Nayak V.S., Subramaniam D.K., Varna R.V., Gautam S.P., Navalgund R.R. and Subrahmanyam G.V. (2011). Report of the Western Ghats Ecology Expert Panel. Submitted to the Ministry of Environment and Forests, Government of India. 522 pp.
Ganguly S. (2015). Deliberating environmental policy in India: Participation and the role of advocacy. Routledge. 196 pp.
Ganguly S. (2019). Civil society and state interaction in environment policy in India. In: Environmental Policy in India (Ciecierska-Holmes, N., Jörgensen, K., Ollier, L.L. and Raghunandan, D. eds.). pp 60-85.
Gill G. (2019). The National Green Tribunal: Evolving Adjudicatory Dimensions. Environmental Policy and Law, 49:(2–3), 153–162.
GoI (2015). India's Intended Nationally Determined Contribution: Working Towards Climate Justice. New Delhi: Government of India. http://www4.unfccc.int/submissions/ INDC/Published% 20Documents/India/1/INDIA%20INDC%20TO%20UNFCCC.pdf
Guha R. (1989). The Unquiet Woods: Economic Change and Peasant Resistance in the Himalaya. University of California Press, 265 pp.
Guha R. (2001). The prehistory of community forestry in India. Environmental History, 6(2): 213-238.
Guha R. and MartÃnez-Alier J. (1997) Varieties of Environmentalism: Essays North and South. London, Earthscan, 230 pp.
Gupta S. (2014). Environmental policy and governance in a federal framework: perspectives from India. In: Environmental policies in Asia: perspectives from seven Asian countries (Huang, J., & Gupta, S. eds.). pp. 15-42.
Hobley M. (1996). Participatory Forestry: The Process of Change in India and Nepal, London, Overseas Development Institute, Rural Development Forestry Study Guide No 3.
Jasanoff S. (1993). India at the crossroads in global environmental policy. Global Environmental Change, 3(1): 32-52.
Kothari A., Singh N. and Saloni S. (Eds.). (1996). People and protected areas: towards participatory conservation in India. Delhi, SAGE Publications Pvt. Limited. 276 pp.
Kumar K. and Kerr J.M. (2012). Democratic assertions: the making of India's recognition of Forest Rights Act. Development and Change, 43(3): 751-771.
Kumar K., Singh N.M. and Rao Y.G. (2017). Promise and performance of the Forest Rights Act. Economic & Political Weekly, 52(25–26): 40-43.
Mandal S. and Rao M.G. (2007). Overlapping fiscal domains and effectiveness of environmental policy in India. In: Environmental Governance and Decentralisation (Breton A., Brosio G., Dalmazzone S. and Garrone G. eds.). Edward Elgar Publishing Limited. pp 223-262.
MoEF (2011). A Handbook, Joint Forest Management, For Front Line Staff of Forest Department & JFMC members. Ministry of Environment and Forests.
MoEF (2014). Assessment of environmental degradation and impact of hydroelectric projects during the June 2013 disaster in Uttarakhand. The Ministry of Environment and Forests Government of India: 226 pp.
MoEFCC (2021): Annual Report 2020-21, Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change, Government of India. Retrieved on 7th July, 2021 at 21:00 from http://moef.gov.in/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/ Environment-AR-English-2020-21.pdf
Mohan A. (2017a). From Rio to Paris: India in global climate politics. Rising Powers Quarterly, 2(3): 39-61.
Mohan A. (2017b). Whose land is it anyway? Energy futures & land use in India. Energy Policy, 110: 257–262.
More M.D. (2016). Green project clearances now in 190 days not in 600 days: Prakash Javadekar. The Indian Express, 22nd May, 2016. Retrieved on 10th July, 2021 at 11:27 from https://indianexpress.com/article/india/india-news-india/greenprojectclearances-now-in-190-days-not-in-600-daysjavadekar2813341/
MoTA (2021): Monthly Progress Report, Ministry of Tribal Affairs, Government of India. Retrieved on 15th July, 2021 at 19:00 fromhttps://tribal.nic.in/downloads/FRA/MPR/2021/(A)%20-%20MPR%20Feb%202021.pdf
Nagpal A. and Jain M. (2019). The Dubious Relationship Between Make in India and Foreign Direct Investment: The Story So Far and the Road Ahead. Paradigm, 23(1): 98–115.
Narain S. (2002). Changing environmentalism. Seminar. pp. 15-20.
Narain S., Panwar H.S., Gadgil M., Thapar V. and Singh S. (2005). Joining the dots: The report of the Tiger Task Force. Project Tiger Directorate, Union Ministry of Environment, Government of India, New Delhi.
NDRF (2020). National Disaster Response Force (NDRF). Retrieved on 4th July, 2021 at 16:00 from http://www.ndrf.gov.in/about-us.
Offenheiser, R.C., and Holcombe, S.H. (2003). Challenges and opportunities in implementing a rights-based approach to development: An Oxfam America perspective. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 32(2): 268-301.
Paglia E. (2021). The Swedish initiative and the 1972 Stockholm Conference: the decisive role of science diplomacy in the emergence of global environmental governance. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, 8(1): 1-10.
PIB (2019). Government clears misgivings of amendment in the Indian Forest Act, 1927. Rights of tribals and forest dwellers to be protected fully, Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change, Government of India. Press th th Information Bureau, 19 June, 2019, Retrieved on 6 July, 2021 at 19:00 from https://pib.gov.in/newsite/PrintRelease.aspx?relid=194511
PIB (2020). MNRE: Year End Review-2020, Ministry of New and Renewable Energy, Government of India. Press Information Bureau, 31 Dec, 2020, Retrieved on 12 July, 2021 at 12:12 from https://www.pib.gov.in/PressReleseDetailm.aspx?PRID=1685046
Ramakrishna K. (1984). The emergence of environmental law in the developing countries: A case study of India. Ecology LQ, 12: 907.
Rangarajan M. (2006). Ideology, the environment and policy: Indira Gandhi. India International Centre Quarterly, 33(1): 50-64.
Rao C.H.H. (2000). Watershed development in India: Recent experience and emerging issues. Economic and Political Weekly, 35(45): 3943-3947.
Reich M.R. and Bowonder B. (1992). Environmental policy in India: Strategies for better implementation. Policy Studies Journal, 20(4): 643-661.
Rengarajan S., Palaniyappan D., Ramachandran P. et al. (2018). National Green Tribunal of India- an observation from environmental judgements. Environ SciPollut Res, 25:11313–11318.
Rights and Resources Initiative (2012). Deeper Roots of Historical Injustice: Trends and Challenges in the Forests of India. Washington, DC: Rights and Resources Initiative.
Sahu G., Dash Tushar and Dubey S. (2017). Political Economy of Community Forest Rights. Economic & Political Weekly, 52: (25-26), 44-47.
Sarin M. (2014). Undoing Historical Injustice: Reclaiming Citizenship Rights and Democratic Forest Governance through the Forest Rights Act. In: Democratizing forest governance in India (Lele, S. and Menon, A. eds.), 100-146.
Shrotria S. (2015). Environmental justice: Is the National Green Tribunal of India effective? Environmental Law Review, 17(3): 169-188.
Springate-Baginski O., Sarin M., Ghosh S., Dasgupta P., Bose I., Banerjee A., Sarap K., Misra P., Behera S., Reddy M.G. and Rao P. T. (2009). Redressing 'historical injustice' through the Indian Forest Rights Act 2006: A Historical Institutional analysis of contemporary forest rights reform. IPPG Discussion Papers, 27, 30p.
T.N. GodavarmanThirumulpad vs Union of India (1996). 9 SCR 982.
Tambe S., French L., Wyborn C., Scarlett L., Defries R., Nagendra H., Kulkarni H., Srivastava P., Agrawal N.K., Rathore B.M.S. and Kinhal G. (2021). India's Environmental Policy Standoff: Reimagining the Stakeholder Engagement Spaces. International Forestry Review, 23(2): 229-239.
Tripathi S. (2018). A Report Card of the NGT at the End of Seven Years Since Establishment: The Present and Future Ahead. Environmental Claims Journal, 30(3): 228-236.
Verma M., Negandhi D., Wahal A.K., Kumar R., Kinhal G.A. and Kumar A. (2014). Revision of rates of NPV applicable for different class/category of forests. Indian Institute of Forest Management. Bhopal, India. 165 pp.
Weible C.M., Heikkila T., Deleon P. and Sabatier P.A. (2012). Understanding and influencing the policy process. Policy Sciences, 45(1): 1-21.
Downloads
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Unless otherwise stated, copyright or similar rights in all materials presented on the site, including graphical images, are owned by Indian Forester.
